Mindful Over Intuitive: Building a Conscious Approach to Eating

The word "intuitive" is defined as "using or based on what one feels to be true even without conscious reasoning; instinctive." This definition illuminates a fundamental misconception in the popular approach to intuitive eating. The suggestion that we should rely purely on instinct and unconscious feelings about food overlooks a crucial reality: our modern relationship with food is anything but instinctive.

---

As a personal trainer working with midlife women for over a decade, I’ve seen firsthand that successful, sustainable nutrition requires more than just instinct—it demands awareness, structure, and intentional practice. Processed foods override natural satiety signals, and factors like stress, marketing, and social pressures further complicate our relationship with food.
This isn’t to dismiss the valuable principles behind intuitive eating, such as rejecting diet culture and honoring hunger signals. However, the term itself can be misleading. What we truly need is a framework that integrates instinct with informed decision-making.

Beyond Intuition: A Mindful and Strategic Approach
Rather than relying solely on intuition, a more effective approach to nutrition involves:
​

• Self-awareness – Recognizing personal hunger and fullness cues.
• Intentional habits – Developing key behaviors that have the biggest impact.
• Flexibility within structure – Maintaining balance without rigid rules.

The SHMEC Framework: A Tool for Awareness
Dr. Jade Teta’s SHMEC framework (Sleep, Hunger, Mood, Energy, and Cravings) provides a structured way to assess and adjust eating patterns based on lifestyle factors:

• Sleep: Poor sleep affects hunger hormones, mood, and energy, often leading to cravings and overeating.
• Hunger: Irregular hunger signals may indicate imbalanced meals or inconsistent eating patterns.
• Mood: Stress and emotions can drive eating choices—tracking mood can help identify emotional eating patterns.
• Energy: Energy dips often trigger cravings for quick-fix foods, but balanced nutrition can prevent this cycle.
• Cravings: Cravings signal deeper needs—whether nutritional, emotional, or lifestyle-related.

Using SHMEC as a feedback tool helps pinpoint the real reasons behind food choices, allowing for strategic adjustments rather than reactive decisions.

Moderation 365: Sustainable, Structured Nutrition
As a certified Moderation 365 coach, I help clients implement a practical, balanced approach to nutrition that removes the stress and obsession around food. Jill Coleman’s Moderation 365 philosophy focuses on satisfaction and structured behaviors instead of rigid rules.

Key Principles:

• Focus on Satisfaction – Eat until comfortably satisfied, not overly full.
• Prioritize Nourishing Foods – Build meals around protein, vegetables, and fiber-rich carbs.
• Release Food Morality – Remove guilt and stop labeling foods as "good" or "bad."
• Practice Intermittent Sampling – Enjoy all foods in moderation to prevent restriction-binge cycles.
• Implement Preemptive "Cheats" – Strategically incorporate enjoyable foods to maintain balance.

The Power of "Big Rocks": Focusing on Impactful Habits
A core concept of Moderation 365 is identifying three key habits—or "Big Rocks"—that have the most significant impact on your health. These behaviors, when consistently practiced, create a foundation for sustainable nutrition.

Examples of Effective "Big Rocks":

• Nutrition Habits: Eating protein at each meal, drinking water before meals, including vegetables in two meals daily.
• Lifestyle Habits: Walking 8,000 steps per day, maintaining a consistent bedtime, practicing stress management techniques.
• Structural Habits: Meal prepping weekly, planning meals ahead, setting up an environment that supports healthy choices.

By focusing on a few high-impact behaviors rather than trying to "eat perfectly," sustainable progress becomes easier.

Integrating Multiple Frameworks for a Balanced Approach
By combining SHMEC, Moderation 365, and principles from intuitive eating, we create a comprehensive approach that acknowledges both the psychological and practical aspects of nutrition:

• Hunger and Fullness Awareness: Intuitive eating emphasizes honoring hunger, while SHMEC helps assess the root causes of hunger fluctuations.
• Emotional and Lifestyle Connection: SHMEC’s mood and energy markers help recognize emotional eating triggers, while Moderation 365 offers structured habits to prevent the restrict-binge cycle.
• Movement and Energy Management: SHMEC monitors how exercise impacts hunger and energy, while Moderation 365 encourages consistency in daily movement.
• Balanced Eating Mindset: Intuitive eating removes food restrictions, SHMEC provides insight into how foods affect the body, and Moderation 365 offers a structured yet flexible way to eat without guilt.

A Practical Strategy for Real Life
For midlife women balancing multiple responsibilities, effective nutrition isn’t about perfection—it’s about developing self-awareness and implementing habits that work consistently.

Daily Action Plan:

1. Morning Check-in: Assess SHMEC markers to guide daily choices.
2. Execute "Big Rocks": Stick to high-impact habits (e.g., prioritizing protein, walking daily, maintaining a bedtime routine).
3. End-of-Day Reflection: Notice how lifestyle factors influenced eating patterns and adjust as needed.

Long-Term Success:

• Use SHMEC as a daily feedback tool.
• Adjust strategies based on life circumstances.
• Prioritize small, meaningful actions over rigid dieting.

Moving Forward: A Balanced Perspective
Rather than relying purely on instinct or following restrictive rules, the key to sustainable nutrition lies in:

• Understanding how lifestyle factors influence food choices.
• Implementing high-impact habits that support long-term success.
• Staying flexible while maintaining consistency.

By blending intuitive awareness, structured habits, and mindful adjustments, we can create a sustainable approach to eating that supports both physical and mental well-being. The goal isn’t to "eat perfectly"—it’s to eat in a way that feels balanced, manageable, and enjoyable for life.